peanut butter chocolate chip cookies. These are universally beloved, and Kathy-beloved. If you haven't tried these cookies yet, you really need to - you will not be the same afterwards.
Cookies weren't enough, so I had to make cupcakes too. With Magnolia Bakery buttercream of course. As it turns out, guys playing poker aren't that into cupcakes getting icing all over their hands. Oh well, more for me!